Article  
Calcium Reduction Using Variations of Thickness and Retention Time of Cocoa  
Shell Activated Carbon  
Afidatul Muadifah1*, Arif Santoso1, Khoirul Ngibad2, Rahma Diyan Martha1, Siti Nurriyatul  
Kholifah1  
1Department of Pharmacy, STIKES Karya Putra Bangsa, Tulungagung 66291, East Java, Indonesia  
2Department of D3-TLM, Universitas Maarif Hasyim Latif, Sidoarjo 61257, East Java, Indonesia  
Abstract  
High levels of hardness can lead to increased cases of kidney stones. Hardness levels can be reduced by  
using activated carbon from the cocoa rind as an adsorbent. The purpose of this research was to  
determine the variation of activated carbon thickness and optimum retention time in reducing the  
calcium content of dug well water, to determine the percent decrease in calcium ion levels at the  
optimum variation, and to determine the significance of the difference in the decreased in calcium levels  
between the treatment groups. The research method used the principle of adsorption of activated  
carbon from cocoa shells to calcium ions, which are activated by KOH. There were ten treatment samples  
with different variations of activated carbon thickness and retention time. The results showed that the  
thickness of activated carbon of 60 cm with a retention time of 50 minutes had the optimum ability to  
reduce the calcium content of dug well water. The percentage decrease in calcium levels reached 89,041  
% with a decreased concentration of 234 ppm. The result of the statistical test showed a significance  
value of 0,05. The conclusion of the research is that activated carbon of cocoa shells can reduce calcium  
levels to the levels of soft water hardness, with variations in activated carbon thickness and retention  
time having a significant effect.  
Keywords: activated carbon; calcium; cocoa; retention time; spectrophotometer UV-Vis  
Graphical Abstract  
*
Corresponding author  
Received 14 April 2023; Accepted 3 July 2023; Available online 30 July 2023  
Copyright © 2023 by Authors, Published by Chempublish Journal. This is an open access article under the CC BY License  
42  
Chempublish Journal, 7(1) 2023, 42-53  
The high level of hardness requires an effort to  
improve public health by applying a method that  
works to reduce hardness levels. One effective  
method is the adsorption process using cocoa  
shell activated carbon. Some studies on activated  
carbon used as an adsorbent include the use of  
activated carbon from palm shells as a filtration  
medium for physical characteristics of water  
covering turbidity, odor, pH and taste. The use of  
palm shells and corn cobs as a heavy metal  
Introduction  
Water is a natural resource that has an important  
role in the continuation of life, so it is necessary  
to have water quality parameters [1]. There are  
several factors that can affect water quality, such  
as geological conditions, aquifer properties,  
lithology and soil type [2]. One factor that can  
reduce water quality is the geological condition of  
an area (Jahanshahi & Zare, 2016). An area with a  
limestone rock composition will potentially have  
high water hardness levels [3]. Based on the  
absorber in batik waste [7], adsorption of lead  
[8]  
metal (Pb) from its solution using corn cobs  
,
Regional  
Environmental  
Status Report  
of  
the use of adsorbents from cocoa shells  
(Theobrema cacao L.) to reduce chemical oxygen  
demand in palm oil mill effluent [9], study of the  
adsorption of hazelnut shell charcoal (Aleorotes  
moluccana) on Iron (III) and Lead (II) ions [10], the  
effectiveness of activated carbon from kluwek  
(Pangium edule) fruit shells and coffee bean  
shells (Coffea arabica L.) on CO and CO gas  
adsorption on the absorption of CO gas and Pb  
particles from motor vehicle emissions [11], the  
use of cocoa shell activated charcoal (Theobrema  
cacao L.) as an absorber of lead metal in used oil  
[12], the use of cocoa fruit shells as an adsorption  
medium for iron (Fe) and manganese (Mn) metals  
in well water [13], and the effectiveness of using  
cocoa shell waste charcoal (Theobrema cacao L.)  
Tulungagung Regency in 2007, 40% of the total  
area of Tulungagung Regency is composed of  
limestone. This allows high levels of calcium in  
water sources. According to Ministry of Health  
Regulation RI [1], the maximum limit of water  
hardness level with the function as consumption  
water is 500 mg/ml. The high level of hardness  
that exceeds the maximum limit can affect public  
health, namely cardiovascular cases [4]. Further,  
[1]  
Ministry of Health Regulation RI number 492  
states that diseases that can be caused by hard  
water are cardiovascular disease (blockage of  
heart blood vessels) and urolithiasis (kidney  
stones). Based on Jain et al. (2010) hardness  
levels above 300 mg/ml can increase the risk of  
kidney stones with long-term consumption. From  
several statements that support the cause of the  
increase in cardiovascular cases, Tulungagung  
Regency recorded cases of hypertension in 2016  
reaching 21,214 cases which ranked fourth out of  
the ten most common diseases [5]. The high  
number of cases is due to a trigger factor, namely  
high hardness levels. In accordance with  
research conducted by Kristina (2013) in  
Semarang, it is known that there is a relationship  
between the hardness of dug well water (p-value  
= 0.001) with the incidence of kidney stones in the  
community in the working area of the Margasari  
Health Center, the results showed that dug well  
water with high hardness is a risk factor for  
kidney stone disease (OR = 4.795). Another study  
conducted by Bobihu in Gorontalo (2012)  
showed that the hardness level of drinking water  
for people with urinary tract stones was 1375.172  
mg/L, while the hardness level of drinking water  
sources for people without urinary tract stones  
to reduce water hardness, salinity and organic  
[14]  
compounds  
.
The adsorption process is an  
event of substance absorption on a solid surface  
with an attractive force [15]. The occurrence of the  
ion absorption mechanism causes activated  
carbon to be able to reduce hardness levels. The  
utilization of cocoa shell as activated carbon is  
based on the content of organic compounds in it.  
Cocoa shell contains 23-54% cellulose[16] while  
cellulose is composed of 44.44% carbon. The high  
carbon content in cocoa shells can produce  
activated carbon with good quality. In previous  
studies, tests have been carried out related to the  
utilization of cocoa shell activated carbon  
including as a lead metal sorbent [12], iron and  
manganese metal adsorption [13], and reducing  
total hardness [14]. This study was conducted to  
determine the effectiveness of cocoa shell  
activated carbon in reducing calcium levels in dug  
well water based on activated carbon thickness  
and retention time.  
was 429.7415 mg/L [6]  
.
43  
Chempublish Journal, 7(1) 2023, 42-53  
The ability of cocoa shell activated carbon to bind  
metal ions, especially calcium, is expected to  
reduce water hardness levels so as to improve  
water quality which in turn can improve the  
quality of public health.  
series of the population of dug wells in the  
village. Sampling points in the dug wells were  
taken from five spots in the well.  
The simulator used is a series of pipes with  
adsorption media arrangement. There are three  
simulators with different thickness of activated  
carbon used.  
Experimental Section  
Materials  
Cocoa shell carbonization[13]  
The materials used include dug well water as a  
sample, cocoa shell activated carbon, murexide  
indicator (ACS), 96% ethanol (ACS), NaOH  
(EMSURE), KOH (Merck) and CaCl2.2H2O (Merck).  
Carbonization is done by a simple method of  
burning cocoa shells in a closed furnace. The  
carbonization process lasts for 2 hours in an  
airtight place. To obtain an airtight condition,  
treatment is given by covering the surface of the  
furnace with wet banana stem fronds, then  
covering it again using a cloth, and the outermost  
layer is covered with soil while the hole cavity that  
can still be penetrated by the burning smoke is  
Instrumentation  
The instrument used to test calcium levels using  
a UV-Vis spectrophotometer brand Inesa UV-Vis  
N4S to increase accuracy with a high degree of  
precision.  
covered with clay [17]  
.
Procedure  
Activation of cocoa shell carbon[18]  
The research method is experimental with  
quantitative identification of the decrease in  
calcium levels. Several stages were carried out as  
follows.  
The activation process of cocoa shell carbon is  
carried out chemically with a 5 M KOH solution  
soaked for 24 hours in a tightly closed container.  
then filtered and washed using distilled water  
until a neutral pH is obtained. The last stage was  
oven drying at 200 °C for 2 hours. Based on SNI  
Sample and simulator preparation[13]  
The sample used is dug well water taken from  
one of the houses in Bulus Village, Tulungagung  
Regency. Based on the profile of Bulus Village,  
geographically Bulus Village is located right on  
the border of Tulungagung Regency and  
Trenggalek Regency (Figure 1), topographically  
located in the lowlands with an altitude of 100 m  
from sea level with an administrative area of  
148,290 Ha. Sampling is a complete random  
(Standar  
Nasional  
IndonesiaIndonesian  
National Standard) 06-3730-1995 on technical  
activated charcoal, good quality powdered  
activated charcoal has a maximum moisture  
content of 15%, a maximum volatile substance  
content of 25%, a maximum ash content of 10%  
and a minimum carbon content of 65% [19]  
.
Figure 1. Map of Bulus village, Bandung sub-district.  
44  
Chempublish Journal, 7(1) 2023, 42-53  
Preparation of the simulator[13]  
The simulator used comes from a paralon pipe  
with a length of 150 cm and a diameter of 2  
inches which is assembled in such a manner.  
Then the preparation of adsorption media is  
carried out. The media that functions as  
adsorption is activated carbon which is arranged  
according to thickness variations.  
d. Standard curve determination  
From 1000 ppm of calcium standard solution, 3  
variants of concentration were made, namely 10,  
100, and 200 ppm. Each concentration was put in  
a 50 mL volumetric flask. Each volumetric flask  
was added with 1 mL of murexide solution then  
a small amount of distilled water. After that, 2 mL  
of 0.1 N NaOH was added and then distilled  
water was added until the limit mark. The  
solution was mixed until homogeneous then put  
into the cuvette and the absorbance was read at  
the maximum wavelength, with the linear  
Adsorption process  
The adsorption process is differentiated by the  
thickness of activated carbon and the retention  
time of water with activated carbon. There are  
three variations of activated carbon thickness  
used, namely 40, 60, and 80 cm. While the  
retention time variations are 30, 40, and 50  
minutes.  
regression equation y = bx + a [20]  
.
e. Determining calcium content in dug well  
water  
1 mL of dug well water sample was taken and put  
into a 50 mL volumetric flask. 1 mL of murexide  
solution and enough distilled water were added.  
Then, 2 mL of 0.1 N NaOH was added to distilled  
water until the limit mark. The solution was  
shaken until homogeneous then put into a  
cuvette and the absorbance was read at the  
Calcium level test  
Calcium level test was conducted on the control  
group and test group after treatment. The test  
was  
carried  
out  
with  
using  
the  
a
UV-Vis  
spectrophotometer  
murexide indicator in an alkaline environment.  
addition of  
maximum  
determined with 3 replications.  
wavelength.  
The  
levels  
were  
a. Preparation of murexide solution  
The preparation of the solution was carried out  
by weighing 50 mg of murexide and then  
dissolved in 10 mL of distilled water, so that a  
concentration of 0.5% was obtained. Next, 25 mL  
of ethanol was added.  
Analysis of results  
To see the significant difference in calcium  
content reduction between treatment groups,  
statistical analysis is needed. The statistical  
analysis used the Kruskal-Wallis comparative test  
to see the difference between variations in  
activated carbon thickness and retention time on  
the decrease in calcium levels in the sample,  
followed by the Mann-Whitney Post Hoc test.  
b. Preparation of calcium standard solution  
Calcium standard solution will be utilized with a  
level of 1000 ppm. The preparation of the  
solution was by dissolving 50 mg of CaCl2.2H2O  
with distilled water up to 50 mL so that a  
concentration of 1000 ppm was obtained.  
Before  
comparative  
conducting  
test,  
the  
normality  
Kruskal-Wallis  
test was  
a
performed, requiring normally distributed data if  
both variables or at least one variable had a  
p>0.05 value.  
c. Determination of maximum wavelength  
From a standard solution with a concentration of  
1000 ppm, 1 mL was taken and put in a 50 mL  
volumetric flask. Then 1 mL of murexide solution  
and a little distilled water were added. After that,  
2 mL of 0.1 N NaOH was added and then distilled  
water was added until the limit mark. The  
solution was mixed until homogeneous then put  
in a cuvette and the absorbance was read at a  
Results and Discussions  
Sample and test media preparation  
Sample selection was based on a complete  
randomized series from the population of dug  
wells in Bulus Village.  
wavelength between 400-800 nm [20]  
.
45  
Chempublish Journal, 7(1) 2023, 42-53  
The sampling technique was done with a  
polypropylene (PP) plastic bucket that had  
previously been rinsed using water from the  
same dug well as the sample. In Indonesia, the  
standard requirements for sample containers  
that can be used are made of glass or  
Tulungagung Regency. The dehydration stage  
was done by drying the cocoa pods with the help  
of sunlight. The carbonization stage was carried  
out by burning in a closed furnace. The  
carbonization process was conducted for ±2  
hours to produce perfectly burned carbon. The  
carbon formed was cut into pieces and then  
activated. The dehydration and carbonization  
process are shown in Figure 3.  
polyethylene plastic (PE) or polypropylene (PP) or  
[21]  
Teflon (Poly Tetra Fluoro Ethylene, PTFE)  
.
Samples were taken ± 20 cm below the water  
surface by visual means. Sampling points are at  
five spots of the well. Samples taken as much as  
20 L were then placed in the same plastic  
container to be homogenized.  
Activation of carbon  
The activation process uses a chemical activation  
method. Chemical activation is the process of  
breaking the carbon chain in organic compounds  
with the help of chemicals. The activating agent  
used was a 5 M KOH solution. The selection of  
KOH as an activating agent is based on research  
conducted by Nurfitria et al.[24] that KOH is a good  
chemical activator for carbon because it can  
increase the surface area up to 3000 m2/g. The  
activation process was carried out by soaking the  
pieces of cocoa shell carbon with 5 M KOH  
solution for 24 hours. After being soaked, it is  
then washed with distilled water until the pH is  
neutral, then continued with an oven at 200 °C  
for 2 hours. The results of curing are in the form  
of activated carbon that is black, odorless, has a  
smooth, shiny surface, is more fragile and lighter.  
The simulator used is a series of PVC pipes with a  
diameter of 2 inches equipped with a faucet at  
the bottom of the pipe in a vertical position. The  
inside of the pipe is set up with adsorption media  
in the form of cocoa shell activated carbon as per  
the thickness variation used. The results of the  
media arrangement are presented in Figure 2.  
Carbonization of carbon shells  
Carbonization is a method to obtain charcoal or  
carbon as the main product [22]. Referring to the  
research of Shofa[23], the carbonization process is  
divided into two stages, namely dehydration and  
carbonization. Cocoa shell waste used as media  
was taken from a plantation in Bulus Village,  
Empty space  
Activated Carbon  
Faucet  
(b)  
(a)  
Figure 2. a) Simulator dan (b) Scheme of the inside of the simulator.  
46  
Chempublish Journal, 7(1) 2023, 42-53  
(a)  
(b)  
Figure 3. Processes of (a) Dehydration dan (b) Carbonization.  
standard solution of CaCl2.2H2O in 1000 ppm.  
The 1000 ppm standard solution was diluted by  
pipetting 1 mL into a 50 mL volumetric flask and  
then adding 1 mL of murexide solution and 2 mL  
of 0.1 N NaOH solution. The addition of murexide  
solution to the standard solution formed a brick  
red color then the addition of NaOH formed a  
concentrated burgundy color. The addition of 0.1  
N NaOH will form a solution with a pH of 12-13 so  
that the solution is in a stable state to form a  
complex. Then distilled water is added to the limit  
mark so that a burgundy-colored solution is  
formed.  
Preparation of test media  
The test media used is an arrangement of  
activated carbon as an adsorbent. The simulator  
circuit with adsorbing agent was divided into  
three media based on the difference in activated  
carbon thickness of 40, 60 and 80 cm.  
Measurement of the density of the activated  
carbon pieces was done visually.  
Adsorption process  
The adsorption process was carried out without  
repetition in each treatment. The sample  
adsorbed in each simulator is equalized in  
volume of 2 L. The filtering results in each  
treatment produce black colored water. This is  
due to the ability of activated carbon to bind  
calcium ions chemically by forming a suspension  
The prepared solution was put into a cuvette and  
the absorbance was read in the wavelength  
range of 400-800 nm. The absorbance readings  
were repeated three times in the visible area. The  
reading results obtained a maximum wavelength  
of 507 nm with an average absorbance of 1.340.  
The spectra of the calcium standard solution  
formed are shown in Figure 4.  
in the sample so that a black color is produced  
[25]  
.
The adsorption process begins with the  
movement of adsorbate molecules towards the  
surface and diffuses on the surface of the  
adsorbent pore forming covalent bonds and  
ionic bonds [26]  
.
Standard curve set up  
Calcium standard curve was made using three  
concentration variations of 10, 100, and 200 ppm  
diluted from 1000 ppm calcium standard  
solution. Then each concentration was added 1  
mL of murexide solution and 2 mL of 0.1 N NaOH  
solution and then marked using distilled water.  
The solution was homogenized then put into a  
cuvette and the absorbance was read at a  
wavelength of 507 nm.  
Calcium level test  
Calcium level test was conducted on the negative  
control group and treatment group with three  
repetitions.  
Determining the maximum wavelength  
Determination of the maximum wavelength is  
done by measuring the absorbance of the  
47  
Chempublish Journal, 7(1) 2023, 42-53  
Figure 4. The spectra of the calcium standard solution.  
Absorbance readings at each concentration  
variation were repeated three times. The results  
of the standard curve absorbance will be shown  
in Table 1.  
the concentration of calcium in the sample. From  
the standard curve formed, a linear regression  
equation y = 0.0015x + 0.4438 was obtained with  
a value of R2 = 0.864.  
Table 1 shows the absorbance value of each  
Determining calcium content in dug well water  
variation  
concentration.  
of  
calcium  
There  
standard  
an  
solution  
increase in  
Calcium content was determined on 10 samples  
consisting of 1 negative control group sample  
and 9 treatment group samples. Each sample  
was prepared for absorbance reading. 1 mL of  
each sample was taken and placed in each 50 mL  
volumetric flask and then added 1 mL of  
murexide, 2 mL of 0.1 N NaOH and marked with  
distilled water.  
is  
absorbance value as the concentration of the  
solution increases. The average absorbance  
results will be presented in the form of a curve  
shown in Figure 5. Figure 5 shows the calcium  
standard curve obtained from the absorbance of  
various calcium concentrations. Presentation  
with a standard curve aims to acquire a linear  
regression equation that will be used to calculate  
Tabel 1. The standard curve absorbance.  
Absorbance  
Calcium  
Average Abs.  
R3  
concentration  
R1  
R2  
10 ppm  
0.422  
0.668  
0.725  
0.420  
0.665  
0.716  
0.429  
0.659  
0.716  
0.424 ± 0.005  
0.664 ± 0.005  
0.719 ± 0.005  
100 ppm  
200 ppm  
Notes:  
R: replication  
Abs.: absorbance  
48  
Chempublish Journal, 7(1) 2023, 42-53  
Ca Standard Curve  
0,8  
0,6  
0,4  
0,2  
y = 0.0015x + 0.4438  
R² = 0.864  
0
0
50  
100  
150  
200  
250  
Concentration (ppm)  
Figure 5. Ca Standard Curve.  
The absorbance reading of each sample was  
done in three repetitions which will be presented  
in Table 2. Table 2 presents the average  
absorbance data of the treatment samples  
conducted in three replications. Based on the  
absorbance value, the negative control group has  
an absorbance value of 0.838 while the  
activated carbon and retention time influence  
reducing calcium levels.  
Based on the average absorbance data, the  
calculation of calcium concentration levels and  
the percentage decrease in levels in each  
treatment was carried out. The results of the  
calculation  
of  
calcium  
concentration  
and  
treatment  
group  
shows  
a
decrease  
in  
percentage reduction are presented in Table 3.  
absorbance. This means that the thickness of  
Tabel 2. Sample Absorbance.  
Treatment  
Absorbance  
R2  
Calcium Level  
Average Abs.  
(ppm)  
Thick (cm) RT (minute)  
R1  
R3  
30  
0,688  
0,570  
0,842  
0,784  
0,613  
0,483  
0,565  
0,516  
0,576  
0,828  
0,690  
0,567  
0,843  
0,790  
0,611  
0,487  
0,564  
0,518  
0,577  
0,831  
0,703  
0,585  
0,908  
0,809  
0,638  
0,485  
0,586  
0,543  
0,577  
0,854  
0,694 ± 0,008  
0,574 ± 0,01  
0,875 ± 0,04  
0,794 ± 0,01  
0,621 ± 0,02  
0,484 ± 0,002  
0,572 ± 0,012  
0,526 ± 0,015  
0,577 ± 0,001  
0,838 ± 0,014  
166,800  
86,800  
287,467  
233,467  
111,467  
28,800  
85,467  
54,800  
88,800  
262,800  
40  
60  
80  
40  
50  
30  
40  
50  
30  
40  
50  
Control (-)  
Notes:  
Thick: Thickness of activated carbon  
RT: retention time  
R1: 1st replication  
R2: 2nd replication  
R3: 3rd replication  
49  
Chempublish Journal, 7(1) 2023, 42-53  
Tabel 3. Calcium level and level decrease percentage.  
Thick  
(cm)  
RT  
(menit)  
Ca Concentration  
(ppm)  
Concentration Decrease  
(ppm)  
%
Decrease  
K -  
0
262,800  
0
0
30  
40  
50  
30  
40  
50  
30  
40  
50  
166,800  
86,800  
287,467  
233,467  
111,467  
28,800  
85,467  
54,800  
88,800  
96  
36,530  
66,971  
-9,386  
11,162  
57,585  
89,041  
67,478  
79,148  
66,210  
40  
176  
-24,667  
29,333  
151,333  
234  
60  
80  
177,333  
208  
174  
Notes:  
Thick: thickness of activated carbon  
RT: retention time  
Based on Table 3, there are eight samples from  
the treatment group that have decreased  
calcium levels when compared to the negative  
control group. The negative control group has a  
calcium level of 262.800 ppm, indicating that the  
water is classified as hard. According to Sutrisno  
(2007) water is classified as hard if it has calcium  
presence of CaO content in cocoa shells allows  
the release of Ca ions in the sample so that the  
calcium content of the treatment sample is  
higher than the negative control. This is in  
accordance with the statement of Bujawati (2014)  
that if the activated carbon is saturated, there will  
be a re-release so the sample after treatment  
levels of 150-300 mg/L [27]  
.
shows an increase in hardness [15]  
.
Furthermore, Table 3 also shows that the  
thickness of activated carbon at 40 cm with  
variations in retention time has an optimal  
reduction rate at a retention time of 40 minutes.  
The 30-minute retention time has a decreased  
level below the 40-minute retention time; this is  
due to the lack of contact time between the water  
sample and activated carbon so that the calcium  
adsorption process is not optimal. While at a  
retention time of 50 minutes there was an  
At a thickness of 60 cm, activated carbon with  
variations in retention time has an increase in  
reducing calcium levels. With variations in  
retention time of 30, 40 and 50 minutes, there  
was an increase in the reduction of calcium levels  
by 11.162%, 57.585% and 89.041%, respectively.  
In accordance with research conducted by  
Bujawati (2014) which compared the thickness of  
activated carbon, the optimum thickness was  
obtained at a thickness of 60 cm with an increase  
increase  
in  
calcium  
concentration  
when  
in the ability to reduce as the retention time  
[15]  
compared to the negative control. This is likely to  
occur due to the saturation of activated carbon  
against the binding of calcium ions. Referring to  
the quality standard of technical activated  
charcoal of SNI 06-3730-1995, the absorption  
capacity of carbon is ≥750 mg/g. The increase in  
hardness levels is a result of several factors, one  
of which is the mismatch between the ratio of  
activated carbon thickness and retention time to  
the volume of sample adsorbed. In addition, the  
prolonged.  
A similar research conducted by  
Ristiana et al. (2009) on the effect of activated  
carbon thickness on hardness reduction showed  
the results of a decrease in hardness levels at a  
thickness of 60 cm activated carbon by 71.54%  
[28]  
.
While another research conducted by  
Nurullita et al. (2010) which compared the effect  
of contact duration showed an increase in the  
percent reduction in levels as the contact  
duration increased [4]  
.
50  
Chempublish Journal, 7(1) 2023, 42-53  
Tabel 4. Statistical test significance value.  
Treatment  
Comparative Treatment  
P
Meaning  
RT 30 Thick 40  
RT 30 Thick 60  
RT 30 Thick 80  
RT 40 Thick 40  
RT 40 Thick 60  
RT 40 Thick 80  
RT 50 Thick 40  
RT 50 Thick 60  
RT 50 Thick 80  
0,050  
0,050  
0,050  
0,050  
0,050  
0,050  
0,275  
0,050  
0,046  
Significant  
Significant  
Significant  
Significant  
Significant  
Significant  
Not Significant  
Significant  
Significant  
K-  
Notes:  
Thick: thickness of activated carbon  
RT: retention time  
Similar research was conducted by Lustiningrum  
(2013) by comparing the effect of the length of  
contact of activated carbon on the decrease in  
hardness levels. The results showed that the  
longer the contact time, the lower the hardness  
calcium levels with variations in activated carbon  
thickness and retention time. The optimal  
variation is obtained at a thickness of 60 cm and  
a retention time of 50 minutes with a percent  
decrease reaching 89.041% or 234 ppm.  
levels [29]  
.
Conclusions  
Meanwhile, at a thickness of 80 cm with  
variations in retention time, the optimal  
reduction rate is reached at 40 minutes with a  
percent reduction of 79.148%. The 50-minute  
Variations in activated carbon thickness and  
retention time can reduce calcium levels of dug  
well water with optimal results at 60 cm activated  
carbon thickness with 50 minutes retention time.  
Percentage decrease in levels reached 89.041%  
with a concentration decrease of 234 ppm and  
has a significance value ≤0.05. Further research  
on the effectiveness of cocoa shell carbon can be  
done by considering the weight of carbon, the  
need to characterize activated carbon with SEM  
or determination of functional groups with FT-IR,  
and the need for comparison with the control  
group +.  
retention time shows  
a
decrease in the  
percentage of calcium content reduction. This is  
due to the saturation of activated carbon at a  
retention time of 50 minutes. This is in  
accordance with the research by Masitoh and  
Sianita (2013) that increasing the retention time  
above the optimal time causes an insignificant  
decrease in calcium levels, because the active  
side of the activated carbon reaches a saturated  
condition so that the adsorption ability decreases  
[30]. The decrease in calcium levels with variations  
in activated carbon thickness and retention time  
has a significance value of ≤0.05 as shown in  
Table 4.  
References  
1. Peraturan Menteri Kesehatan Republik Indonesia  
Tentang Persyaratan Kualitas Air Minum, Pub. L.  
No. Nomor 492/Menkes/Per/IV/2010, 1 (2010).  
The significance value of ≤0.05 indicates that the  
variation of activated carbon thickness and  
retention time has an influence on the ability to  
reduce calcium levels of dug well water which is  
significantly different. This is as shown in Table  
4.3 regarding the percentage of decrease in  
2. Jahanshahi, R., & Zare, M. (2016). Hydrochemical  
investigations for delineating salt-water intrusion  
into the coastal aquifer of Maharlou Lake, Iran.  
Journal of African Earth Sciences, 121, 1629.  
51  
Chempublish Journal, 7(1) 2023, 42-53  
3. Rohma, W.,  
&
Sutedjo, A. (2018). Analisis  
Kesadahan Air Tanah Dangkal Dalam Kaitannya  
Dengan Kebutuhan Air Domestik Di Sekitar Bukit  
Kapur Sadeng Kecamatan Puger. Swara Bhumi,  
5(9), 15.  
4. Nurullita, U., Astuti, R., & Arifin, M. Z. (2020).  
Pengaruh lama kontak karbon aktif sebagai media  
filter terhadap persentase penurunan kesadahan  
CaCO3 air sumur artetis. Jurnal Kesehatan  
Masyarakat Indonesia, 6(1).  
14. Juwita, A. I., Ahmad, I., Musdalifah, Bujawati, E., &  
Basri, S. (2018). Efektivitas Penggunaan Arang Aktif  
Limbah Kulit Kakao (Theobroma cacao L.) untuk  
Menurunkan Kesadahan, Salinitas dan Senyawa  
Organik. Higiene , 4(1), 110.  
5. Badan Pusat Statistik Kabupaten Tulungagung.  
(2021). Sepuluh Penyakit Terbanyak Menurut  
15. Bujawati, E., Rusmin, M., & Basri, S. (2014).  
Pengaruh ketebalan arang tempurung kelapa  
terhadap tingkat kesadahan air di wilayah kerja  
Puskesmas Sudu Kabupaten Enrekang tahun  
2013. Urnal Kesehatan, 7(1).  
Jenisnya Menurut Kecamatan Tahun 2016  
ehatan.html  
.
6. Bobihu, R. (2012). Uji Kadar Kesadahan Sumber Air  
Minum pada Kejadian Penyakit Batu Saluran  
Kemih di Desa Barakati Kecamatan Batudaa  
Kabupaten Gorontalo . Public Health Journal, 1(1),  
37245.  
16. Hasanah, M. (2019). Pengaruh Suhu Pemanasan  
Terhadap Karakteristik Dan Mikrostruktur Karbon  
Aktif Kulit Kakao. Jurnal Laminar , 1(1), 2227.  
17. Sulistyo, J., Marsoem, S. N., Kholik, A., & Wibowo,  
M. N. (2017). Proses Pengarangan Dari  
Tungku/Dapur Pengarang Konvensional Dan  
Ermanen Di Wonosari, Gunung kidul. Proseding  
Seminar Nasional Masyarakat Peneliti Kayu  
Indonesia XX; MAPEKI (Masyarakat Peneliti Kayu  
Indonesia), 206216.  
7. Sukarta, F. (2014). Pemanfaatan Arang Aktif  
Tempurung Kelapa Sawit Dan Tongkol Jagung  
Sebagai Adsorben Logam Berat Pada Limbah Batik.  
Institute Pertanian Bogor.  
8. Ningsih, D. A., Said, I., & Ningsih, P. (2016).  
Adsorpsi Logam Berat timbal (Pb) Dari Larutannya  
Dengan Menggunakan Adsorben Dari Tongkol  
Jagung. Jurnal Akademika Kimia, 5(2), 5560.  
18. Asmar, D., Viena, V., & Elvitriana, E. (2021). Aktivasi  
Karbon Aktif Dari Kulit Pisang Awak (MUSA  
Paradisiaca L.) Secara Kimiawi Dan Aplikasinya  
Pada Adsorpsi Fe dan Mn Air Sumur . Karya Ilmiah  
Fakultas Teknik (KIFT), 1(2), 3645.  
9. Setiaty Pandia, Astri Devi Yunita Siahaan, & Anita  
Tiurmaida Hutagalung. (2017). Pemanfaatan  
Adsorben Dari Kulit Buah Kakao (Theobroma  
cacao l.) Untuk Menurunkan Chemical Oxygen  
Demand Pada Palm Oil Mill Effluent. Jurnal Teknik  
19. Arang Aktif Teknis, Pub. L. No. SNI 06-3730-95  
(1995).  
Kimia  
USU,  
6(3),  
3440.  
20. Rahayu, W. S., Utami, P. I., & Kurniawati, A. (2011).  
Validitas Penetapan Kadar Kalsium Dalam Sediaan  
Tablet Multivitamin Secara Spektrofotometri UV-  
10. Yuniar, Y., Mappiratu, M., & Nurhaeni, N. (2015).  
Kajian Daya Serap Arang Tempurung Kemiri  
(Aleorites Moluccana) Terhadap Ion Besi (III) Dan  
Ion Timbal (II) Pada Berbagai Waktu Kontak.  
Vis.  
PHARMACY:  
Jurnal  
Farmasi  
Indonesia  
(Pharmaceutical Journal of Indonesia), 8(2), 3441.  
21. Air Dan Air LimbahBagian 58: Metoda  
Pengambilan Contoh Air Tanah, Pub. L. No. SNI  
6989.58 (2008).  
KOVALEN,  
1(1),  
3035.  
01  
22. Ridhuan, K., & Suranto, J. (2017). Perbandingan  
Pembakaran Pirolisis Dan Karbonisasi Pada  
Biomassa Kulit Durian Terhadap Nilai Kalori.  
Turbo: Jurnal Program Studi Teknik Mesin, 5(1), 50–  
11. Nurhayati, N., & Zikri, Z. (2020). Efektifitas Karbon  
Aktif Cangkang Buah Kluwek (Pangium edule) Dan  
Cangkang Biji Kopi (Coffea arabica L.) Terhadap  
Daya Serap Gas CO Dan Partikel Pb Emisi  
Kendaraan Bermotor. Jurnal Penelitian Dan Karya  
Ilmiah Lembaga Penelitian Universitas Trisakti, 5(1),  
23. Shofa. (2012). Pembuatan Karbon Aktif Berbahan  
Baku Ampas Tebu Dengan Aktivasi Kalium  
Hidroksida. Universitas Indonesia.  
12. Ferawanda. (2021). Pemanfaatan arang aktif kulit  
kakao (Theobrema cacao L.) sebagai penyerap logam  
timbal dalam oli bekas. Universitas Tadulako.  
24. Nurfitria, N., Febriyantiningrum, K., Utomo, W. P.,  
Nugraheni, Z. V., Pangastuti, D. D., Maulida, H., &  
52  
Chempublish Journal, 7(1) 2023, 42-53  
Ariyanti, F. N. (2019). Pengaruh Konsentrasi  
Aktivator Kalium Hidroksida (KOH) pada Karbon  
Aktif dan Waktu Kontak Terhadap Daya Adsorpsi  
Logam Pb dalam Sampel Air Kawasan Mangrove  
Wonorejo, Surabaya. Akta Kimia Indonesia, 4(1), 75–  
28. Ristiana, N., Astuti, D., & Kurniawan, T. P. (2009).  
Keefektifan ketebalan kombinasi zeolite dengan  
arang aktif dalam menurunkan kadar kesadahan  
air sumur di karang tengah weru kebupaten  
sukoharjo. Jurnal Kesehatan, 2(1), 91102.  
29. Lustiningrum, I. A. (2013). Pengaruh Lama Kontak  
Karbon Aktif Terhadap Penurunan Kadar Kesadahan  
Air Sumur Di Desa Kismoyoso Kecamatan Ngemplak  
Kabupaten Boyolali. Universitas Muhammadiyah  
Surakarta.  
25. Qonita, H. N., Izah, M., Harahap, N. A. H., &  
SUmantri, I. (2019). Pengurangan Kesadahan Ca  
Dan Mg Dengan Karbon Aktif Dan Pengaruhnya  
Terhadap Kelayakan Konsumsi Pada Air Tanah Di  
Dusun Sambirejo, Kelurahan Talak Broto,  
Kecamatan Simo, Kabupaten Boyolali. Prosiding  
Seminar Nasional Kebumian Ke-12, 808814.  
30. Masitoh, Y. F., & Sianita, B. M. M. (2013).  
Pemanfaatan Arang Aktif Kulit Buah Coklat  
(Theobroma cacao L.) Sebagai Adsorben Logam  
Berat Cd (II) Dalam Pelarut Air. UNESA Journal of  
Chemistry, 2(2), 2327.  
26. Prabowo, A. L. (2009). Pembuatan Karbon Aktif dari  
Tongkol Jagung Serta Aplikasinya Untuk Adsorpsi Cu,  
Pb, dan Amonia. Universitas Indonesia.  
27. Sutrisno, T. C. (2007). Teknologi Penyediaan Air  
Bersih. Rineka Cipta.  
53